1.consistency
2.routine quality
3.gains
This 3 are pretty good criteria, still easy to lie about it.
I rather not compete with a prize, but as rocky and BSA said it's mike's generosity which I really appreciate.
I think we should add pics before and after every comp,one measure for all bpfl and mseg?
Maybe no judges? if there's no one willing to(personally I'll be willing to judge) the competition will become bigger with time,maybe we should keep it under 10 people. we can all judge at some point,especially if someone already won.
If not judges, popular vote within the competitors
So this is my option to decide a winner.
1.MOST WINNER OF ROUTINE OF THE WEEK.(routine quality) 3 of these would be first place automatically
We should set the same day every week to post your vote, You have 24 hours to, whoever not posted clearly not committed, looses points if we go based on point system, this would be part of the consistency criteria.
Personally I don't always have time to log in my journal,plus i make the same routine all week, so rewrite doesn't work, I think BSA said the same, some maybe we can at least write up something to let know routine was done as proof of consistency(takes less than 4 mins)
2.BIGGEST GAINERS. If you went over certain amount of gain in a month you'll be first place
If there's a tie, winner we'll be decide by judges or competitors based on the 3 criterias. so your journal will be 50% gains 50%
I believe this is not the ultimate way to decide, hopefully we can come up with something from this.
Just an Idea