Just my 2 cents...
I think some people here are honest and some are full of shit. Just like every other facet of life. You have your mods that have "power" egos here. Just like you have to deal with people like that in life. I don't get so wrapped up in it... I just don't care. If that's what these people need to give meaning to their life, then go for it.
I agree that if you claim a huge stat and refuse to post a measured pic, you should not whine about doubters questionig you. I'm not trying to turn this into Red-bashing thread, but if you look at his pics next to the can (a soft drink can is 4.75" tall btw), it doesn't look (to me) like he has another 3+" of dick below the can (hard to say for sure, but I tried to ID the vein patterns in both pics as a ref). Another thing, if you take the 2.1" wide comment from his sig and apply the std formula that Grave noted above you get a girth of just under 6.6". If the dick was a perfect cylinder, the width would have to be a hair over 2.25" to get 7.1". Does this prove he's not the size he claims? No, he may be as big as he claims, but it does give reason people to doubt. Red has every right not to post measured pics, but claiming huge size and posting crappy inconclusive pics is worse than no pics at all, to a lot of people.
Yes, it is hard for some to get a raging boner when taking a measured pic (I know from experience), but you can show a lot with a 80% hard on, or you can measure clamped, like Titelist did in his thread.
Overall, I really don't care that much. Do I think Red fudges his #s? Yes I do, but pobably not a lot. That doesn't mean he is not a valuable member of the forum. And as was noted earlier, unsubstantiated claims really don't do anything to legitimize Penis Enlargement to the outside world, but that's fine with me. I have no interest in it catching on widespread. If I were D, I would want Red to post some clear measured pics (even if not fully erect), BUT, then again, even if people do prove their huge sizes, you will still have doubters that say, 'He was just born big, Penis Enlargement didn't do that.' That's just human nature.