Like Prince Albert, I know exactly where you are coming from. I too had very little newbie gains, then afterward my gains were very small and far between. Considering how long I've been at this for the amount of intensity, there are many people who have gained way more with the same workload or less. The way I see it though, it isn't even really a choice for me. Once I decide I want something I will stop at nothing to get it. I want a monster between my legs, and if it takes me ten years of sacrificed time, stashing vaseline, money on devices, messy hands, discolored skin, and cramping fingers I will get it. Hanging with a Bib starter was the only thing that seemed to give me really consistent length gains. Of course I was about 2 years into Penis Enlargement when I tried that. I'm still trying to figure out my honeypot for girth gains, I may have found something but I don't want to jinx it by saying thats definitely true.
Prince Albert is right, it really is all trial and error. Like I see many people have gained huge girth from clamping, but it just doesn't work for me. If you really want to leave then at least you know this exists, and I think you may try it again. I wish I been able to get on a forum like this when I was younger and first started experimenting with Penis Enlargement. It probably would have given me a great deal more guidance. So its up to you, but if it was easy everyone would be doing it.